|Year : 2014 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 16-22
Treatment pathways of extrapulmonary patients diagnosed at a tertiary care hospital in Delhi, India
Manoj Grover1, Neelima Bhagat1, Nandini Sharma1, Meera Dhuria2
1 Department of Community Medicine, Maulana Azad Medical College, New Delhi, India
2 Department of Epidemiology, New Delhi Tuberculosis Centre, New Delhi, India
|Date of Web Publication||29-Jan-2014|
Department of Community Medicine, Maulana Azad Medical College, New Delhi - 110 002
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
| Abstract|| |
Background: In order to put extrapulmonary tuberculosis patients early on treatment, it is important to study pathways, which these patients adopt in for seeking treatment. Materials and Methods: In order to study the treatment pathways of extrapulmonary patients and assess appropriate points for intervention, a cross-sectional study was conducted in chest clinic of a tertiary care hospital in Delhi. Results: Factors associated with longer paths included reason for going to first health facility (nearness and known provider), availing more than one health facilities, presenting symptoms of fever, joint pain, nodular skin swelling and skin lesion. Self-referral to the chest clinic was associated with shorter paths. Lower level of education, occupation, non-serious perception of the disease and visiting five health facilities were significantly associated with patient delay of more than 3.5 weeks. Symptoms of fever, joint pain and skin lesion, visiting private health facility first, availing more than two health facilities and travelling distance of more than 100 km to reach chest clinic were significantly associated with the health facility delay of more than 4.5 weeks. Conclusions: Increasing public awareness, training of private practitioners and capacity building of government facilities will help in reducing delay.
Keywords: Behavior, extrapulmonary, health facility delay, patient delay
|How to cite this article:|
Grover M, Bhagat N, Sharma N, Dhuria M. Treatment pathways of extrapulmonary patients diagnosed at a tertiary care hospital in Delhi, India. Lung India 2014;31:16-22
|How to cite this URL:|
Grover M, Bhagat N, Sharma N, Dhuria M. Treatment pathways of extrapulmonary patients diagnosed at a tertiary care hospital in Delhi, India. Lung India [serial online] 2014 [cited 2017 Dec 13];31:16-22. Available from: http://www.lungindia.com/text.asp?2014/31/1/16/125888
| Introduction|| |
In India, pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) is the most common form of tuberculosis (TB) accounting for 75-90% of all types of TB. Extrapulmonary tuberculosis (EPTB) constitutes 10-15% of TB cases and accounts for more than 50% of all cases of TB in HIV+ patients. 
In developed countries, a slower annual decrease in EPTB case counts in comparison to PTB case counts has been reported. , In India, both pulmonary and extrapulmonary cases notified under Revised National Tuberculosis Control Programme (RNTCP) have increased since 1999. However, the rate of increase of new extrapulmonary cases is more than that of new sputum positive or negative TB cases.  In a study conducted at LRS Institute of TB and Respiratory Diseases, Delhi, EPTB to PTB ratio was found to change significantly from 1:5 at the start in January 1999 to about 1:3.5 in March 2003.  This increase in numbers has social and economic consequences in a developing economy.
Studies from other countries have shown that TB patients follow a variety of pathways to seek care, which can lead to delayed treatment.  It is also well documented that EPTB is associated with a greater patient and diagnostic delay in comparison to PTB. , Such studies particularly among EPTB patients are lacking in India.
The present study was conducted to chart the treatment pathways of extrapulmonary patients to assess appropriate points for intervention.
| Materials and Methods|| |
The study was conducted from December 2008 to April 2010 at the chest clinic of a teaching hospital in Delhi, India. A directly observed treatment short course (DOTS) cum microscopy center is located at the chest clinic catering to a designated population. The chest clinic refers patients to their respective DOTS clinic after diagnosing. 150 newly diagnosed EPTB patients in the chest clinic were included in the study. A pre-tested semi-structured questionnaire was administered after taking written informed consent from patients, on alternate days in a week. Information was recorded regarding health-care seeking behavior and time delays; time from the onset of symptoms to the first consultation (T1), referral to designated TB health facility (T2), and finally the diagnosis and initiation of treatment (T3). Ethical clearance was taken from the institutional Ethics Committee. Data was entered and analyzed with the help of Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) 16.0 (IBM SPSS Statistics, IBM Corporation, Chicago, IL). Appropriate statistical tests were applied.
Delay was defined as time elapsed from:
- Onset of symptoms to the first consultation at any health facility (patient delay T1).
- First health facility to referral to a TB facility (referral delay T2).
- Referral to TB facility till the diagnosis (diagnostic delay T3).
Health facility delay included both referral and diagnostic delay (T2 + T3) and total delay included both patient and health facility delay (T1 + T2 + T3).
| Results|| |
Mean age of the participants was 23.2 years (SD = 11.1 year). There were more females 82 (54.7%) than males 68 (45.3%). Median monthly per capita income was Rs. 666.8 (interquartile range [IQR] 412-1000). Maximum subjects were unmarried (88; 58.7%).
40 (26.7%) subjects were illiterate while 45 (30%) were just literate or received primary (studied upto 5 th grade) school education (45; 30%).
Majority of the subjects were unemployed (103; 68.7%). Among those who were employed, 16 (10.6%) were daily wage workers and others were involved in small business (6; 4%) or in service (25; 16.7%).
Majority (136; 90.7%) of the participants resided in urban areas. The distribution according to type of area was: Regular colonies (60; 40%), walled city (42; 28%), Jhuggi Jhompdi (JJ) cluster 26 (17.3%), resettlement colony, unauthorized colony (4; 2.7% each).
Health seeking behavior of the patients
Average number of health facilities visited irrespective of the number of repeated visits were 1.99 (median 2; IQR = 1-2, range 1-5). Median distance travelled to reach chest clinic (TB facility) was 100 km (IQR = 100-400).
Most common symptom, which made patients seek health-care was nodular skin swelling (70; 46.7%) followed by fever (40; 26.7%), chest pain (13; 8.7%), abdominal pain (10; 6.7%), joint pain (7; 4.7%), skin lesion (2; 1.3%), cough, loss of appetite and discharging sinus (1; 0.7% each).
Most common site involved was lymph nodes (96; 64%) followed by pleura (25; 16.7%), abdomen (14; 9.3%), bone/joint (7; 4.7%), skin (5; 3.3%), eye (2; 1.3%) and female reproductive organs (1; 0.7%).
Self-reported reasons for visiting first health-care facility
Maximum patients had first visited a private health facility (86; 57.4%) while 64 (42.6%) visited government health facility first, which included government hospital (57; 38%), dispensary (5; 3.3%) and DOTS center (2; 1.3%).
Reasons for going to any first health facility where nearness (98; 65.3%), cost (17; 11.3%), better quality (11; 7.3%), already on some treatment from the same facility (9; 6%), other family member took treatment from the same facility (4; 2.7%), knew staff working at the facility (7; 4.6%) and others (4; 2.7%).
Most common reason for going to a private facility first was nearness (82; 95.3%) and for government health facility it was also nearness along with perception of better quality (16; 25% each) and low cost (10; 15.6%) by the patients.
Patient care seeking pathways to TB diagnosis
Care seeking pathways were traced from the onset of symptoms to final diagnosis of EPTB at the chest clinic. Thirteen different pathways were identified [Figure 1].
Median patient delay in pathways varied from 1 to 44 weeks [Table 1]. Median health facility delay ranged from 2 to 39 weeks. Overall median total delay in these pathways ranged from 6 to 78 weeks.
Only 18 (12%) patients were referred to chest clinic by a private practitioner while the rest were referred either by another government facility (102; 68%) or by self (30; 20%).
Characteristics of patients who adopted the long paths
Paths were divided into three groups on the basis of median total delay: Less than 9 weeks (shorter paths; group 1), 9-16 weeks (medium length paths; group 2), and above 16 weeks (longer paths; group 3) [Table 2].
Health-care seeking behavior of patients who followed longest paths (group 3) differed from those following medium paths (group 2) as they tend to choose nearest health facility or the one where they knew a provider and consult more than one provider (P > 0.05).
Symptoms of fever, nodular skin swelling, abdominal pain, and joint pain were significantly associated with patients who followed the longer paths (group 3) in comparison to those who followed the shorter paths (group 1) (P = 0.04).
Although the difference in the two groups (group 3 and group 2) was not significant with respect to the referring agency, it was observed that referral to the chest clinics by government (91; 68.9%) was higher in medium length paths in comparison to longer paths (9; 64.3%).
Referral to chest clinic by self was significantly associated with shorter paths (group 1) in comparison to medium length paths (group 2) (P = 0.02).
Delay in health-care seeking
Median patient delay was 3.5 weeks (IQR = 2-8). Median referral and diagnostic delay were 3 weeks (IQR = 1-8.2) and 2 weeks (IQR = 1-2). Median health facility delay was 4.5 weeks (2-10) and median total delay was 12 weeks (IQR = 4-16).
Median patient, health facility, and total delay in females (4, 6, and 12 weeks respectively) were significantly higher than those in males (2, 4, and 8 weeks respectively).
Maximum median total delay was seen in patients in whom site of EPTB was eye (26.5 weeks) followed by abdomen (16 weeks), lymph node tuberculosis (LNTB), joint TB, skin TB (12 weeks each) and pleural effusion (4 weeks) [Table 3].
|Table 3: Patient delay, health facility delay, and total delay in study subjects by the site of EPTB|
Click here to view
Median referral delay was maximum in those patients who were referred to chest clinic by private practitioners' (5 weeks; IQR = 1-10) followed by self-referred (4 weeks; IQR = 1-9) and government (2 weeks; IQR = 2-7) (P = 0.059; median test).
All types of median delays increased with an increase in the number of health facilities availed (P < 0.05; median test).
Factors significantly associated with patient delay of more than the median value (3.5 weeks) were younger age (≤30 years), female gender, residence in a lower socioeconomic area (rural area, resettlement colony, JJ cluster), education only up to primary level, occupation such as laborer, cultivator, student, retired, housewife and the patients' perception that disease was not serious.
Patients' delayed health-care seeking was significantly associated with symptoms such as eye redness, skin lesion, and discharging sinus and health-care seeking behavior that included visiting a private health facility first and availing more than four health facilities [Table 4].
Factors significantly associated with health facility delay of more than 4.5 weeks were residing in an urban area, female gender, being occupied as laborer, unemployed, student, housewife, retired, having monthly per capita income of less than or equal to Rs. 500.
Fever, joint pain, and skin lesion were symptoms significantly associated with health facility delay.
Health-care seeking behavior significantly associated with health facility delay were availing more than two health facilities, going to a private health facility first, travelling a distance of more than 100 km to the chest clinic and referral to chest clinic by a private practitioner or self [Table 5].
|Table 5: Factors associated with health facility delay (T2T3) >4.5 weeks*|
Click here to view
On binary logistic regression, factors which were significantly associated with patient delay were an education level up to primary, being occupied as laborer, skilled worker, student, retired, housewife, perception that the disease is not serious, and availing five health facilities.
Residence (i.e., urban areas), symptoms of fever, joint pain and skin lesion, availing first health facility as private, availing more than two health facilities and travelling distance of more than 100 km to reach chest clinic were significantly associated with health facility delay of more than 4.5 weeks [Table 6].
|Table 6: Predictors of patient delay and health facility delay of more than the median value|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
Studies on health-care seeking pathways and delays in PTB patients are available from many countries including India, China, and Ethiopia. ,, However, published literature did not show similar studies in EPTB patients.
Patients with EPTB manifest site specific symptoms along with constitutional symptoms.  In India, LNTB continues to be the most common form of EPTB. Hence, predictably, this was the first symptom responsible for treatment seeking in the majority (70; 46.7%).
Preferred first health-care facility was private (86; 57.4%) chosen for being the nearest one. Similar findings were observed in a survey, in which, 53.4% patients also preferred a private facility over government.  This implies the importance of sensitizing private practitioners to management of EPTB as has been done more for PTB cases in the program. Patients, who preferred government health facility, did so for nearness, followed by its perceived good quality and low cost. However, other studies show that the government facilities are perceived as low quality. , Further studies are required to see if this is so because people perceived their symptoms as suggestive of a disease requiring long-term treatment and high cost.
In order to link all health-care providers with RNTCP, Government of India approved Non Government Organisations/ Public Private NGO/PP schemes in 2000-2001, which have been updated from time to time. Intensified scale up of public private mix (PPM) has shown improvement in case detection of pulmonary TB and notification rates by providers.  A similar approach needs to be extended to EPTB management.
In the present study too, the majority were referred to the chest clinic (TB facility) by another government facility (102; 68%) thereby indicating the program's greater success in the government sector. A study from Mysore, India showed that only less than half of the doctors in the private sector prescribed DOTS compared to 95.1% in the government sector. 
The fact that 30 patients (20%) had come to the chest clinic on their own is an indirect indicator of the awareness generation done in Delhi. Poor referral by private practitioners (18%) is a matter of grave concern as they are the first health-care providers for the majority.
Symptoms such as fever, abdominal pain and joint pain, which are not specific to EPTB, were significantly associated with longest paths in comparison shortest paths. These symptoms, being constitutional are not considered in the differential diagnosis of EPTB. This could be due to the fact that duration of symptoms is not considered due to the multiplicity of providers visited.
Referral to chest clinic by self was significantly associated with shortest paths (group 1) in comparison to medium length paths (group 2). This indicates that the general population should be sensitized regarding EPTB so that they seek treatment at the earliest from TB health facilities as has been seen in case of PTB. 
Median patient delay was 3.5 weeks (IQR = 2-8) in our study. Median patient delay in EPTB patients reported in other studies are 12.8 weeks (90 days) in Ethiopia, 8.6 weeks in New York, 6 weeks in Norway and 1.6 weeks in Vietnam. ,,,
In our study, patient delay for joint TB and LNTB was 12 weeks each though in Scotland, it was 28 weeks and 26 weeks respectively in Caucasians.  Awareness about the possibility of TB in a patient with lymph node swelling or joint pain needs to be raised for seeking early treatment in the general population.
Median health facility delay in our study (4.5 weeks) was similar to the one reported in a study from Vietnam (4.6 weeks).  Though a delay of only 1.5 weeks was reported from Ethiopia and 6 weeks from Norway. ,
Maximum health facility delay seen in patients in whom site of EPTB was skin (8 weeks) followed by LNTB, bone/joint TB (6 weeks) and abdominal TB (5.5 weeks). This calls for increasing the involvement of concerned specialists in these fields through training programs.
Median total delay was 12 weeks, which is similar to the finding in Norway (11.5 weeks). 
However, in Vietnam median total delay was 6.5 weeks and 26 weeks in Ethiopia. ,
In our study, median total delay was 8 weeks in females which is similar to median total delay in women developing TB during pregnancy. 
Although systematic review among PTB patients shows no difference in delay in developing and developed countries, such studies are lacking in EPTB patients. 
| Implications for the Program|| |
Greater health facility delay was seen when patient sought care from a private health facility first probably because of lower involvement of private practitioners in the TB program, also reflected in the poor referral. This indicates that they are either not suspecting TB in most of the EPTB patients are not aware of the government facilities where TB is treated or are not motivated to refer suspected TB cases to government facilities. In any of these cases, special initiative is required to increase the participation of private sector in the TB program.
Increasing public awareness especially about the various disease presentations can help reduce patient delay. There is a need to have standardized training modules and IEC materials created by experts.
Sensitizing the public specifically on EPTB in addition to PTB, symptoms/disease presentations and availability of drugs under RNTCP free of cost, continuing medical educations for respective specialists and faculty of teaching institutions in addition to programs for private practitioners (PPs) and involvement of PPs will help in lowering the burden of disease and improve the quality of life of those affected
Limitations of the study
Health seeking behavior and time delay in treatment seeking was recorded based on memory of the study subjects. Recall bias by study subjects is an important limitation of the study. Self-reporting of smoking, alcohol consumption and dependence on drugs was low. Therefore, their contribution in treatment delays cannot be elicited.
| Acknowledgments|| |
The study received thesis grant from "Delhi Tapedik Unmulan Samiti." Study sponsors had no role in the study design, in the collection, analysis and interpretation of data; in the writing of the manuscript; and in the decision to submit the manuscript for publication.
| References|| |
|1.||Sharma SK, Mohan A. Extrapulmonary tuberculosis. Indian J Med Res 2004;120:316-53. |
|2.||Peto HM, Pratt RH, Harrington TA, LoBue PA, Armstrong LR. Epidemiology of extrapulmonary tuberculosis in the United States, 1993-2006. Clin Infect Dis 2009;49:1350-7. |
|3.||García-Rodríguez JF, Álvarez-Díaz H, Lorenzo-García MV, Mariño-Callejo A, Fernández-Rial Á, Sesma-Sánchez P. Extrapulmonary tuberculosis: Epidemiology and risk factors. Enferm Infecc Microbiol Clin 2011;29:502-9. |
|4.||Central TB Division, DGHS. TB India 2011. Revised National TB Control Programme. Annual Status Report. GOI. New Delhi: Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Nirman Bhawan; 2010. |
|5.||Arora VK, Gupta R. Trends of extra-pulmonary tuberculosis under revised national tuberculosis control programme: A study from South Delhi. Indian J Tuberc 2006;53:77-83. |
|6.||Camara A, Bah-Sow OY, Baldé NM, Camara LM, Barry IS, Bah B, et al. Impact of care pathway on the delay for initiation of antituberculosis treatment in Conakry, Guinea. Med Trop (Mars) 2009;69:241-4. |
|7.||Mesfin MM, Tasew TW, Tareke IG, Kifle YT, Karen WH, Richard MJ. Delays and care seeking behaviour among tuberculosis patients in Tigray of Northern Ethiopia. Ethiop J Health Dev 2005;19: 7-12. |
|8.||Rossato Silva D, Müller AM, Dalcin Pde T. Factors associated with delayed diagnosis of tuberculosis in hospitalized patients in a high TB and HIV burden setting: A cross-sectional study. BMC Infect Dis 2012;12:57. |
|9.||Selvam JM, Wares F, Perumal M, Gopi PG, Sudha G, Chandrasekaran V, et al. Health-seeking behaviour of new smear-positive TB patients under a DOTS programme in Tamil Nadu, India, 2003. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2007;11:161-7. |
|10.||Wang WB, Jiang QW, Chen Y, Xu B. Pathways from first health care seeking to diagnosis: Obstacles to tuberculosis care in rural China. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2007;11:386-91. |
|11.||Yimer S, Bjune G, Alene G. Diagnostic and treatment delay among pulmonary tuberculosis patients in Ethiopia: A cross sectional study. BMC Infect Dis 2005;5:112. |
|12.||Hazarika I. Role of private sector in providing tuberculosis care: Evidence from a population-based survey in India. J Glob Infect Dis 2011;3:19-24. |
|13.||Pinto LM, Udwadia ZF. Private patient perceptions about a public programme; what do private Indian tuberculosis patients really feel about directly observed treatment? BMC Public Health 2010;10:357. |
|14.||Lal SS, Sahu S, Wares F, Lönnroth K, Chauhan LS, Uplekar M. Intensified scale-up of public-private mix: A systems approach to tuberculosis care and control in India. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2011;15:97-104. |
|15.||Nagaraja V, Sankapithilu GB, Khan MA. DOTS awareness and the myths and misconceptions about DOTS among medical practitioners in Mysore. Online J Health Allied Sci 2012;11:8. Available from: http://www.ojhas.org/issue41/2012-1-8.htm . [Accessed on 2013 Jul 22]. |
|16.||Sharma N, Taneja DK, Pagare D, Saha R, Vashist RP, Ingle GK. The impact of an IEC campaign on tuberculosis awareness and health seeking behaviour in Delhi, India. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2005;9:1259-65. |
|17.||Sarmiento K, Hirsch-Moverman Y, Colson PW, El-Sadr W. Help-seeking behavior of marginalized groups: A study of TB patients in Harlem, New York. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2006;10:1140-5. |
|18.||Farah MG, Rygh JH, Steen TW, Selmer R, Heldal E, Bjune G. Patient and health care system delays in the start of tuberculosis treatment in Norway. BMC Infect Dis 2006;6:33. |
|19.||Lönnroth K, Thuong LM, Linh PD, Diwan VK. Delay and discontinuity - A survey of TB patients′ search of a diagnosis in a diversified health care system. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 1999;3:992-1000. |
|20.||Moudgil H, Leitch AG. Extra-pulmonary tuberculosis in Lothian 1980-1989: Ethnic status and delay from onset of symptoms to diagnosis. Respir Med 1994;88:507-10. |
|21.||Llewelyn M, Cropley I, Wilkinson RJ, Davidson RN. Tuberculosis diagnosed during pregnancy: A prospective study from London. Thorax 2000;55:129-32. |
|22.||Sreeramareddy CT, Panduru KV, Menten J, Van den Ende J. Time delays in diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis: A systematic review of literature. BMC Infect Dis 2009;9:91. |
[Table 1], [Table 2], [Table 3], [Table 4], [Table 5], [Table 6]